Local Advertising Ideas Demonstrated With A Cleaning Service Ad Featuring The Headline Do You Like It Squeaky Clean And A Schedule A Free Estimate Call To Action

I Made 100 Local Ads Before I Asked Anyone To Pay Me

Years ago, I heard somebody give a piece of advice about learning advertising.

They said something like:

If you want to understand advertising, copy 100 great advertisements word for word.

The idea was that somewhere along the way, after writing headline after headline and studying how the words worked, you would start to understand how an advertisement talks to the person looking at it.

I thought that sounded cool.

So naturally, I didn’t do it.

But years later, without really realizing it, I ended up creating my own version of the exercise.

Instead of copying 100 advertisements…

I made 100 of them.

There Was Another Reason For The Number 100

At the time, I had this idea for what was basically an electronic version of Valpak.

I had owned a pool service on Long Island and made my own advertising for the business.

I loved that part.

Coming up with the headline.

Finding the image.

Then one day I was walking back from the mailbox flipping through the coupon mailers.

Plumbers.

Roofers.

Restaurants.

Dentists.

Pool companies.

Landscapers.

Page after page after page.

And I remember thinking:

We can do better than this.

I don’t mean that disrespectfully.

Those mailers obviously work or companies wouldn’t keep sending them.

Sometimes I think businesses keep advertising this way because they don’t know what else to do.

There isn’t an alternative, so they keep doing what they think they’re supposed to do.

But so many of the advertisements felt like what my mom calls:

Word salad.

Logo.

Phone number.

Twenty services.

Three coupons.

Website.

Financing available.

Licensed and insured.

WE GOT YOU COVERED.

Everything screaming for attention at exactly the same time.

Eventually your brain just shuts off.

I knew there was a better way.

What If The Coupon Magazine Was Digital?

My idea was to create something similar, except every business could have an incredible digital advertisement that led to its own landing page.

A local electronic magazine.

If I could eventually get 100 businesses paying every month, I knew I had something. 

And if I was going to ask 100 businesses to advertise with me…

I figured I should probably learn how to make 100 advertisements.

So I started.

I Made A List Of Local Businesses

I asked ChatGPT for basically every type of local business I could think of.

House Cleaners.

Roofer.

Restaurant.

Pool company.

Photographer.

Hair salon.

Moving company.

Electrician.

Dentist.

Surf shop.

Mobile notary.

Dog walker.

Music instructor.

Magician.

Local Advertising Ideas Demonstrated With A Fictional Magician Ad For Adrian Velaro Featuring A Black Top Hat, Playing Cards And The Headline Magic You Won’t Believe

The list got long.

And that was the point.

I wanted to know whether I could look at almost any local business and find an interesting way to advertise it.

So I started going down the list.

A lot of the real businesses I chose were already advertising in coupon mailers and Valpak.

My thinking was simple:

They already believed in advertising.

I didn’t have to convince them that advertising mattered.

I just had to show them something better.

Because plenty of local business owners still believe:

Word of mouth is all I need.

Advertising is a rip-off.

And marketers—especially digital marketers—haven’t exactly done themselves any favors earning trust.

Some of the advertisements were based on real businesses.

Some were completely made up.

Some were generic enough that I could change the logo and adapt the idea to another business in the same category.

That became another lesson.

A good advertising idea for a plumber doesn’t necessarily belong to one plumber.

There are a lot of plumbers in the United States.

I’m not suggesting I pimp out the exact same ad to every plumber in the Jupiter area.

But a plumber in Kalamazoo, Tallahassee, Toledo or Huntington can all use the same dynamite advertising idea without anybody getting their feelings hurt.

It’s almost like a fitting in the plumber’s truck.

The basic part can work in a lot of different houses.

You just have to adapt it to the job.

The business name wasn’t always the important part.

The idea was.

Could I make somebody stop?

Could I make them feel something?

Could I make them understand the message quickly?

Could I make them want to know more?

That was the exercise.

It Took A Long Time

I didn’t sit down one weekend and crank out 100 advertisements.

It took more than a year.

And it was on and off.

I’d get inspired, make a few, then weeks or months would go by while I questioned my worth, my sanity and probably the entire idea.

Eventually I stopped negotiating with myself.

Do the 100.

One a week if that’s what it takes.

Just finish.

And somewhere along the way, the advertisements started turning into landing pages.

Which introduced another small problem.

I didn’t really know how to build websites.

So now I wasn’t only trying to learn advertising.

I was learning web design.

That tacked another year onto the adventure.

And there was a lot of bad work during that period.

Really bad.

The ad above is one of my earlier attempts—and it just keeps going and going. More tips. More ideas. More offers. All good stuff, but each deserved its own moment instead of being crammed into one ad.

It took me a while to understand the advice from Lee Clow’s Beard:

“When writing copy, start with the one message you absolutely [must] get across. Then stop.”

Some Of My Early Work Makes Me Cringe

I still have the advertisements.

I still have old business pages.

Old videos.

Old offers.

Some of them look like a third grader discovered Canva during indoor recess.

I cringe.

But I don’t regret them.

Because that’s the part nobody can skip.

You can watch 100 videos about advertising.

You can take courses.

Read books.

Listen to experts.

Study examples.

All of that helps.

But eventually you have to stop studying advertising and make an advertisement.

And then another one.

And another.

And another.

You have to be willing to make terrible stuff.

Then slightly less terrible stuff.

Then something that makes you think:

Wait a minute. That’s pretty good.

And then you keep going.

Roofing Ad Reading “Buy A New Roof” And “Go To Hawaii On The House” Over A Lush Coastal Landscape.

Somewhere Along The Way, The Headlines Got Shorter

I was always pretty good with words.

Winter Springs Into Summer’s Fall Through All The Sea’s Suns.

It’s like writing lyrics.

You start hearing where words can be removed.

You become more comfortable saying less.

My headlines got shorter.

The ideas got bolder.

The advertisements became simpler.

And that ended up helping with the web design too.

One line fits better than five.

A short headline usually looks better on a phone.

One visual idea is easier to understand than seven.

Eventually I came across Donald Miller and started applying some of what he teaches about clarity and messaging.

That reinforced something I was already starting to discover.

Say less. Mean more.

Local Advertising Ideas Represented By The Long Island Pool Services Lips Logo Featuring A Pink Lipstick-Print Graphic And Spaced Lips Lettering

Simple And Creative Usually Wins

That’s probably the biggest thing I learned from making all those advertisements.

You have no time.

I’ve said before that you have nanoseconds to get somebody’s attention.

They’re scrolling.

Driving past something.

Opening the mailbox.

Looking at a refrigerator.

Scanning a website.

Whatever the medium is, they’re probably not sitting there waiting patiently for your advertisement to explain itself.

So I keep coming back to the same idea:

Simple + creative.

Make the idea easy to understand.

Then make the way you say it interesting enough that somebody notices.

That’s much harder than filling the page with information.

I Already Knew I Could Come Up With The Idea

One of my pool customers years ago was a roofing contractor.

He wanted to advertise.

I came up with:

What Happens Under Your Roof Stays Protected By Ours

The video showed rain hitting a roof while the words slowly faded in over a Hawaiian-style melody.

The line was my twist on:

What happens in Vegas stays in Vegas.

I remember showing it to them.

At first it was:

“Oh, that’s nice.”

Then it landed.

“Wow. I love that.”

That little delay is one of my favorite parts of advertising.

The sentence is simple.

You understand it immediately.

Then your brain catches the twist.

That’s advertising.

What I wasn’t comfortable doing was selling it.

I Was A Terrible Salesman

If my dad were still here, he’d back me up on this one.

I could come up with the advertisement.

I could make the thing.

Then I’d get in front of somebody and completely fumble the sale.

I didn’t have a sales process.

I didn’t know what came next.

I didn’t know how to take somebody from:

“That’s really cool.”

to:

“Where do I pay?”

And that’s probably one of the biggest reasons Boofkay has taken as long as it has.

I didn’t only need better advertisements.

I needed a system around the advertisements.

That’s What I’m Building Now

The goal today is different.

I want the entire process to be stupid simple.

You should be able to see what it is.

Understand what you’re getting.

See examples.

Choose what you need.

Give me the information.

And get started.

As easy as ordering a pizza.

I’ll still be here if you need me.

But you shouldn’t need me standing in front of you giving some polished sales pitch to understand why the idea works.

The work should sell itself.

That’s what I’m trying to build with Boofkay.

And in a strange way, that’s what I was trying to build with that electronic magazine almost ten years ago.

Then Magnetic Menus Showed Up

A while back, I was in a Skool group where Tony Norris showed us a refrigerator magnet advertising idea.

And immediately my brain started putting things together.

The local advertising.

The digital magazine.

The landing pages.

The 100 advertisements.

The idea of giving businesses a better way to get noticed.

And now a physical object sitting inside someone’s home.

That eventually became part of the thinking behind AdsThatStick and The Jupiter Edition.

So those 100 advertisements weren’t some side project that disappeared.

They became training for what I’m building now.

I Never Copied The 100 Ads

I still think about that original exercise sometimes.

Copy 100 advertisements word for word.

Maybe I should have done it.

Maybe it would have taught me something.

But I’m glad I ended up doing it my way.

I created.

I failed.

I made ugly stuff.

I made better stuff.

I learned web design because the advertisements needed somewhere to go.

I learned how to make offers.

I learned how headlines work on a screen.

I learned that creativity doesn’t mean ignoring the framework.

I learned that simple usually beats complicated.

And somewhere around advertisement number 100, I stopped wondering whether I knew how to make an ad.

The question became:

How do I build a system that lets me do this for other businesses?

That’s the part I’m working on now.

Did I Make An Ad For Your Business?

There’s a pretty good chance.

I created advertisements for around 100 different kinds of local businesses while I was learning how to do this.

So tell me what you do.

If I’ve already made an advertisement for your type of business, I’ll dig through the toolbox and show you what I came up with.

And if I haven’t?

You may have just given me advertisement number 101.